Starfish Rentals Your Gateway to Unique Coastal Getaways!
About Us
At Starfish Rentals, we turn your vacation dreams into reality with our carefully curated selection of exquisite rental properties. Discover your ideal home away from home, perfectly positioned to offer you an exceptional coastal experience.
Nestled near some of the most sought-after beaches in Southwest Florida, Vanderbilt Beach, Bonita Beach, Lovers Key, Fort Myers Beach, and Barefoot Beach feature unique amenities and local charm that make every stay memorable. With a tropical savanna climate year-round, you can expect warm temperatures and plenty of sunshine, making it the perfect destination for beach lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.
Adventure awaits! Engage in thrilling activities such as jet skiing, parasailing, fishing, kayaking, and paddle boarding, or simply relax and soak up the sun while suntanning on the pristine beaches. As passionate foodies, we also know the best local restaurants and culinary hotspots to enhance your stay.
Immerse yourself in the stunning beauty of Southwest Florida while enjoying all the comforts of home. Our thoughtfully equipped rentals come with essential amenities and delightful touches that create lasting memories. Whether you’re traveling with family, enjoying a romantic escape, or seeking a solo adventure, we have the perfect space for you.
Choose Starfish Rentals for your next vacation and start creating cherished moments that will stay with you forever!

Meet Joey & Melanie:
Your Experienced Hosts
Our journey through life has been filled with ups and downs, shaping us with who we are today. With a background in owning a travel agency, we’ve traveled the world—exploring three continents, embarking on over fifty cruises, and experiencing stays at charming, remote, and five-star properties globally. Our passion for different cuisines has culminated in our New York Inn, where we operated a fine dining restaurant and two bed & breakfasts for a decade.
Joey’s remarkable voice and musical talent have allowed him to pursue his passion, bringing joy to many through his performances. A well-established figure in the Southwest Florida area, he delights audiences with his uncanny ability to emulate the artists he covers. Discover more at www.joeyfiato.com
Now, we are pursuing a simpler life by the beach, dedicated to helping others realize their vacation dreams through Starfish Rentals.
Join us, and let your coastal getaway begin!